Makeup Air Units in Winter: Balancing Ventilation and Building Heat

Why exhaust-related drafts happen—and what Central Ohio facility managers should check before turning up the thermostat.

The building feels comfortable until production starts. Then exhaust fans turn on, cold air moves through doorways, and employees ask for more heat.
The problem may involve more than the furnace or boiler.
Your facility could be struggling to replace the air its exhaust systems remove—or to heat that replacement air adequately.
Makeup air units in winter deserve attention in manufacturing facilities, food-production buildings, commercial kitchens, and other exhaust-heavy operations.
Understanding their role helps owners and facility managers investigate comfort complaints without undermining ventilation.
In This Guide
What a makeup air unit does
Why winter changes the heating requirement
Tempered air versus space heating
Common winter symptoms
What to document before service
Improvements and frequently asked questions
What Does a Makeup Air Unit Do?
A makeup air unit supplies replacement air for air removed from a building by exhaust systems.
It may also filter, heat, or cool that air, depending on its design.
ASHRAE explains that exhausted air must be replaced either through an intentional strategy or through available leakage and openings.
Poorly planned makeup air can contribute to drafts and interfere with exhaust-system performance. [1]
Think about a facility operating process exhaust, restroom exhaust, and a kitchen hood at the same time.
The building needs a coordinated replacement-air strategy for that combination.
That does not mean every unit should supply exactly the airflow of one exhaust fan.
Other outdoor-air supplies, transfer air between spaces, and intended pressure relationships all belong in the assessment.
The goal is the correct airflow relationship for the application.
Some spaces intentionally operate negative to adjacent areas; making every room positive is not the objective.

Why Makeup Air Units in Winter Require More Heat
An exhaust system can move the same amount of air on a mild afternoon and a bitterly cold morning. But heating the replacement air takes more energy as the outdoor temperature drops.
A simplified calculation shows how that heating requirement changes:
Heating output ≈ 1.08 × airflow (SCFM) × temperature rise (°F)
SCFM stands for standard cubic feet per minute.
It expresses airflow at standard air conditions, providing a consistent basis for the calculation.
Temperature rise is how much warmer the incoming air needs to become. Heating outdoor air from 10°F to 65°F requires a 55°F temperature rise.
The result is the approximate heat delivered to the air in Btu/h—British thermal units per hour. The 1.08 factor assumes standard-density air; equipment calculations must use the appropriate density and airflow basis.
Heat delivered to the air is different from the fuel input needed to produce it. CaptiveAire’s heating calculator distinguishes between these values. [2]
Example: Heating 5,000 SCFM to 65°F
The airflow and target discharge temperature stay the same in each scenario. Only the outdoor temperature changes.

Outdoor Temperature | Temperature Rise | Approximate Heat Delivered to Air |
40°F | 25°F | 135,000 Btu/h |
25°F | 40°F | 216,000 Btu/h |
10°F | 55°F | 297,000 Btu/h |
0°F | 65°F | 351,000 Btu/h |
At 0°F, heating this airflow to 65°F requires 2.6 times as much heat as it does at 40°F.
These are illustrative calculations, not equipment sizing recommendations. The outdoor temperatures are scenarios rather than Columbus design temperatures, and 65°F is not a universal discharge setpoint. The figures exclude humidification and other loads and do not represent burner input or total building heat loss.
Practical takeaway: A makeup air unit that delivers comfortably tempered air on a mild day needs substantially more heating output to maintain that same discharge temperature during a cold spell.
Tempered Air Is Not Always Space Heating
Heating cold outdoor air before it enters your building does not necessarily mean the makeup air unit is responsible for keeping the entire space warm. Its role depends on how the system was designed and how its controls are configured.
Some units maintain a set temperature for the air they discharge. Others respond to room temperature and supply warmer air to help heat the space. Greenheck describes both approaches in its makeup air controls guidance. [3]

If a unit supplies 65°F air to a 65°F room, it brings replacement air up to room temperature—but provides no additional sensible heat to offset heat escaping through the walls, roof, or other openings. That remaining heating load still needs to be met.
Before raising a setpoint, ask:
Is this unit intended only to temper replacement air?
Is it also designed to provide space heating?
Which temperature sensor controls its output?
What equipment serves the remaining building load?
A cold room does not automatically mean the makeup air unit is malfunctioning.
Understanding its intended role helps identify whether the problem involves the unit, its controls, or the equipment responsible for heating the space.
Know Which Heating System You Have
ASHRAE lists direct-fired gas, indirect-fired gas, electric resistance, steam, and hot-water heating options for makeup air equipment. [4]
Heating Type | Useful Question for Your Contractor |
Direct-fired gas | Are burner airflow and operating conditions within the unit’s approved requirements? |
Indirect-fired gas | Have the heat exchanger, combustion system, and venting been evaluated? |
Hot water or steam | Is the required heat supply available, and is freeze protection appropriate? |
Electric resistance | Are the commanded heating stages actually operating? |
Direct-fired equipment introduces combustion products into the heated airstream; indirect-fired equipment uses a heat exchanger.
Selection must suit the application. Hydronic makeup air heating sections exposed to freezing conditions also need a deliberate protection strategy. [4]
Use the installed model’s documentation when evaluating performance or proposing changes.
Common Winter Symptoms and What to Investigate
Cold Drafts Begin When Exhaust Fans Start
Record which fans started and where drafts appeared. Ask for a review of replacement airflow, distribution, and pressure relationships under those operating conditions.
ASHRAE specifically identifies makeup air distribution as important to limiting uncomfortable cross-drafts and maintaining effective local exhaust. [1]
The Supply Fan Runs, but the Air Feels Cold
Capture the displayed discharge temperature, its setpoint, heating status, and any fault message.
A running fan does not prove that the heating section is operating.
A technician can then distinguish insufficient heating output from a control, sensor, or operating-sequence issue.
The Unit Shuts Down During Cold Weather
Document the exact alarm and what other equipment continues running.
Greenheck describes protective sequences that can stop makeup air operation when adequate tempering is unavailable; protection for water or steam coils differs from gas-heating protection. [3]
Do not repeatedly reset a fault or bypass a protective control. Have the complete supply-and-exhaust response reviewed.
One Work Area Is Cold While Others Are Comfortable
Note the location of supply outlets, door activity, and exhaust pickup points. Ask whether the air reaches the intended area without creating disruptive drafts.
Raising the temperature at the unit may not resolve a distribution problem.
What Facility Managers Should Record Before Service
Use normal operator displays, existing building automation access, and safe observations.

Record | Include |
Outdoor conditions | Temperature and time of the complaint |
Discharge air | Actual temperature and active setpoint |
Heating operation | Heat command, available output indication, and faults |
Supply and exhaust | Which units are running and their schedules |
Building conditions | Affected areas, door activity, and pressure readings if available |
Recent changes | Added exhaust, modified production, maintenance, or overrides |
Keep measured airflow separate from fan-speed commands.
A displayed frequency or percentage is not a field measurement of delivered CFM. Likewise, a configured design-airflow value is not necessarily a live airflow reading.
CaptiveAire’s industrial-unit manual illustrates why controls context matters: it includes space- and discharge-temperature functions, outdoor reset, schedules, and configured design values. Available features depend on the installed system. [5]
Download our Makeup Air Winter Checklist & Operating Log to document operating conditions, organize information for your HVAC contractor, and track performance after service.
Improve Performance Without Compromising Ventilation
Start by comparing actual operation with the intended design. Useful review items include:
Supply and exhaust schedules that no longer match production.
Temporary overrides that remain active.
Filter or intake restrictions.
Discharge sensors that do not reflect actual conditions.
Changes to exhaust demand since commissioning.
Heating capacity under colder outdoor conditions.
Variable airflow can be useful where the application supports it, but adjustments must preserve exhaust performance and equipment limits.
Greenheck notes that its direct-fired variable-airflow arrangements need provisions to maintain the required burner airflow conditions. [3]
Do not solve a heating complaint by disabling required process exhaust or closing outdoor-air dampers.
Coordinate operating changes with the responsible service and ventilation professionals.
For owners reviewing a proposal, request the measured findings, the proposed correction, and a verification plan.
After work is complete, compare discharge temperature, airflow, comfort, and faults under similar conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a Makeup Air Unit the Same as a Rooftop HVAC Unit?
Not necessarily. “Rooftop” describes location or equipment configuration. Makeup air describes the replacement-air function.
Confirm what each unit supplies and which systems it serves.
Should Makeup Air Always Be Supplied at Room Temperature?
No single setpoint fits every application.
The right discharge temperature depends on distribution, comfort requirements, and whether the unit also provides space heating. [3][4]
Can We Reduce Makeup Air to Save Heating Energy?
Only after verifying the required replacement airflow, pressure relationships, and equipment limitations.
A reduction that disrupts exhaust capture or necessary ventilation is not an acceptable correction.
What If the Problem Started After We Added an Exhaust Fan?
Include that change in your service request.
Ask whether the replacement-air system and heating capacity were reassessed for the new operating condition.
Get Help With Makeup Air Performance in Central Ohio
Cold drafts, inadequate tempering, and exhaust-related comfort complaints are easier to investigate when airflow, heating, and controls are considered together.
Engineered Temperature Solutions helps Central Ohio commercial and industrial facilities address HVAC and ventilation needs.
If your building becomes uncomfortable when exhaust systems operate, start with an evaluation of the conditions causing the complaint.
Contact ETS to discuss a ventilation evaluation. Bring your equipment details, operating schedule, and any available temperature or alarm records.
Chris Godwin
“Outstanding service from start to finish… professional, knowledgeable, responsive, prompt, efficient, and exceptionally thorough.”
Brad Ginger
“They’ve handled electrical work, plumbing, boiler repair, and more. Anything I needed done, they could handle. Highly recommend.”
Rob Orlowski
“Always helpful, personable, and ready to respond with repairs or advice. My number-one call for commercial HVAC equipment help.”
Key Takeaways
Exhausted air must be replaced through planned air supplies or other paths into the building.
Airflow and heating performance are separate questions; investigate both.
Heating incoming air to a neutral temperature does not necessarily heat the building itself.
Colder outdoor air increases the heating required for the same replacement airflow.
Record operating conditions before changing fan speeds, setpoints, or ventilation schedules.
Sources
ASHRAE. ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications: Ventilation of the Industrial Environment. — Makeup air, air distribution, exhaust performance, and pressure relationships; used for engineering principles, not current code requirements.
CaptiveAire Systems. HVAC Calculator Toolbox: Heating Performance. — Sensible-heating calculations, air-density corrections, and heating output versus fuel input.
Greenheck Fan Corporation. Make-Up Air FAQs. — Discharge and space-temperature controls, protective sequences, and variable-airflow considerations; details are equipment-specific.
ASHRAE. ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Systems and Equipment: Unit Ventilators, Unit Heaters, and Makeup Air Units. — Heating types, makeup air applications, and hydronic freeze-protection principles.
CaptiveAire Systems. Industrial Makeup Air Unit Installation, Operation, and Maintenance Manual. — Model-specific control functions, operating settings, and monitoring information.






Comments